Join me in Pt. 2: A blind listening test! https://youtu.be/aSbyIBrQzgo
Follow me here:
Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/pauldavids
Twitter: https://twitter.com/paulmdavids
I am comparing a Martin D-42 to a Motion TD-107.
Both guitars are miced exactly the same way:
Same distance to the mic; same angle to the neck; same height, same room temperature; same humidity; same dude playing the songs; same gain on the pre-amp; same output level of the track used in the DAW, same swea… OOPS, DIFFERENT SWEATER!11!!
What do you listen to when testing guitars? What are the differences in sound? Close your eyes, and give it a test!
***Preferably listen to it on decent speakers, or headphones***
*SONGLIST*
John Mayer – Who Says
Beatles – Here Comes The Sun
Bluegrass lick
Ed Sheeran – I See Fire
Avicii – Wake me Up
Coldplay – Fix You
Price: $39.99
Best Choice Products 38in Beginner Acoustic Guitar Starter Kit w/Case, Strap, Digital E-Tuner, Pick, Pitch Pipe, Strings (Black)
38-INCH ACOUSTIC GUITAR: Right-handed guitar delivers a full-bodied sound with its all-wood design, 19 frets, steel strings, and an attractive finish ULTIMATE STARTER KIT: Perfect for beginner guitarists, it includes a guitar pick, shoulder strap, pi... (as of August 8, 2020 - More infoProduct prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.)
Price: $89.99
Best Choice Products 41in Full Size Beginner Acoustic Cutaway Guitar Set w/Case, Strap, Capo, Strings, Tuner - Sunburst
ALL-INCLUSIVE GUITAR SET: Beginner acoustic guitar set comes complete with a strap, capo, digital tuner, polishing cloth, set of 4 guitar picks, and additional strings FULL-SIZE BODY: Comfortably designed with a 41-inch, user-friendly body perfect fo... (as of August 8, 2020 - More infoProduct prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.)
Price: $54.93
Pyle 6 String Acoustic Guitar, Right, Natural (PGACLS82)
36” BEGINNER GUITAR SET: Pyle brings you a complete all-in-one acoustic guitar set, everything you need to start playing! The guitar comes with a gig bag case, pitch pipe tuner, spare strings, pearloid picks, cleaning cloth, and a gift card JUNIOR SC... (as of August 8, 2020 - More infoProduct prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.)
Price: $49.95
YMC 38" Blue Beginner Acoustic Guitar Starter Package Student Guitar with Gig Bag,Strap, 3 Thickness 9 Picks,2 Pickguards,Pick Holder, Extra Strings, Electronic Tuner -Blue
(640)
Martin, is so much crisper and better tone!
No Difference. Now a days a Chinese Stratocaster is just as good as a Fender USA !!!
they are both nice but for me martin was the best, it sound very smooth
The Martin seems to have a natural compression…and sounds far more brightly…
During the first piece I preferred the Motion but then switched over to the Martin. But I had to go back to the start to check which guitar was what. I wish he had simply recorded clean with no compression and reverb. Personally I play a classical guitar but am looking at a steel string to get the sound I want. I just didn’t realise all the tonal differences when I bought it a few years back and only recently really started learning. I think the $500 mark is about right for me as it should play ok and my playing will be the blocker. When I improve then I may look again.
That Martin sounds nice, but it doesnt smell as good as three thousand dollars in new bills.
IMO, once you go past $2000 you’re just throwing money away…unless it’s worth it to you of course.
Wow! I am basically a aural sommelier for a living. One of my most important jobs is making violins sound as good as they can. It is like night and day listening to these two guitars. I have no vested interest in either of these instruments, in fact in general I haven’t cared too much for the Martin guitars I have heard. One thing I can tell many people who might watch a video like this is that when spending more money on any instrument it becomes more and more about nuance and subtlety. It is ridiculous to think that any guitar can sound five times better than another guitar when talking about generally well made instruments. The Martin definitely wins hands down in every category in this test. It absolutely has more clarity, more complex overtone structure, better blend from high to low, and more character. It costs much more because it is much more refined. That refinement isn’t for everyone and the less expensive guitar sounds pretty good for the price.
you can tell the peavy is the cheap one cause it’s a peavy
Martin sounds better
Wow.. I like guitars hoping someday i have one of those things
What is the song in 2:03? Please
@5:44 Those are great chords for the song “Fix You”
I’ve played cheap acoustics, and I’ve played expensive Martin’s. Martin’s are nice, but sound aside, what you’re paying for is playability. I can tell he’s fighting the cheaper guitar to get the desired sound, which takes more work and more effort.
I can make the $5000 sounds like $150 ._.
didn’t hear $5000 dif
Im wandering how many people could tell the difference without looking.
the shape reminds me of a pear
Please do a tutorial on how to play fix you!!
The Martin sounded better, but the cheap guitar was not too bad. I hate that first style you played, where you slap the guitar to make a beat. Many players I hear do this, and I hate it. Let the audience tap their foot to the beat in your music, but do not do it for them with that very annoying slapping on the guitar.
Huge difference and Im not a very good player
No sabía que el capitán América tocaba la guitarra que shido
Check out this $150 vs $3500 electric guitar comparison: Fender Custom Shop USA vs Squier strat CHINA. Can you hear the difference?
https://youtu.be/7LYfaCYg4Is
It sounds same !!
Martin is best
Awesome video dude! Love the editing skills!
QWhat was the song you played on capo 6?
The discussion reminds me of the joke: Why do dogs lick their balls? Because they can! If you could spare the cash get the Martin. You won’t regret it.
i think d-42 is best
Motion is better
What is the tune at 4:40 please Paul?
Which guy is Paul and which one is David ?
Moin
yeah it is nice kind a sound both of them , not much diffrence the warmt is a bit cleaner on the martin, the other is the roots wher it start yknow indeed respect for that but love for music multiplies for much varieties haha but good job nice style keep going ur a star in coming! 😉
The guy on the left is clearly the better looking.
I will pay 150 for the Martin which sounds exactly like the other
What’s the last song? Sounds so familiar but I can’t seem to get it.
I see fire
5:45 whats the tuning please?
Great job, great video…thanx for taking the time to make it. I’m sure ur students know how lucky they are….
Why am i watching this, don’t even play the guitar…
Martin every day of the week and twice on sunday
the differance doesn’t come close to justifying the cost. I have a $99.00 electric guitar from Walmart I have been fine tuning & it sounds good.
At least by what I can tell by the video (and that might make a considerable difference), there’s no fucking way that the Martin sounds $4,850 better than the other one. It does sound “richer” to some extent, and it sounds considerably better for soloing, but I honestly preferred the brighter sound of the cheaper guitar for full-out strumming (again, at least from what I can tell from the video).
damn good guitar for 150 sounds ok ,,but cant compare it
Would have been better to compare them with a standalone mic. Picup quality isn’t necessarily the same as the acoustic capability.
A really fair comparison would have been between 2 instruments with the same wood. The rosewood is going to sound more mellow and the mahogany brighter.
Great tone relies on a guitar that stays in tune. The rest is in the hands.